Animal-based foods and human health throughout evolution - A review of the evidence
The original study links the agricultural transition to skeletal signs of poorer health, including dental problems, infections, and bone loss. Subsequent studies confirm that settlement, population growth, and dependence on crops could increase certain stresses, but the effects varied across regions, diets, and cultural practices, requiring cautious and contextualized interpretations.
- Published 09/11/2026
- Updated 11/11/2026
- Article history
ABSTRACT
The analyzed study reconstructs, in a narrative form, some major changes in human diet throughout evolution. The part relevant to the book's section concerns the transition to agricultural production that began approximately 10,000 years ago: according to the author, the increased reliance on cultivated grains and the lower consumption of meat were associated, in ancient human remains, with more dental problems, signs compatible with iron-deficiency anemia, infections, and bone loss.
In section 1.1.3 of "The Choice to Live in Health or Illness" by Dr. A. Colonnese and R. Panzironi, the publication thus contributes to the narrative that some ancient agricultural populations showed a worsening of archaeological health indicators. Independent studies on Neolithic communities support the existence of greater biological pressures in specific agricultural contexts, including growth stress, increased exposure to diseases, and an increase in certain dental pathologies. However, other studies do not detect a uniform dental deterioration. The most prudent conclusion is that the agricultural transition may have increased certain health risks, but with different effects depending on location, period, foods consumed, and living conditions.
Analyzed study
The research question was how the consumption of animal-based foods, especially meat, changed during human evolution and what consequences these changes may have had on health. The hypothesis discussed is that the transition from hunting and gathering to a diet based more heavily on domesticated grains narrowed dietary variety and coincided with a worsening of certain indicators observable in skeletal remains.
The relevance to paragraph 1.1.3 of “The Choice to Live in Health or Illness” by Dr. A. Colonnese and R. Panzironi is precise: the study is referenced for the passage describing more frequent cavities, dental occlusion alterations, signs attributed to iron-deficiency anemia, infections, and bone tissue loss following the advent of agriculture. The analyzed study can support this general archaeological framework; however, it cannot prove that cultivation, grains, or the reduction of meat were the sole cause of each observed lesion.
Since the available material is only the abstract, it is not possible to verify in detail how the author selected the specimens, populations, or studies cited in the summary.
Materials and methods of the original study
The publication is a narrative synthesis of evolutionary history, archaeology, and human health, not a clinical study or an experiment on contemporary participants. The abstract describes three major phases: the opportunistic acquisition of meat before 2 million years ago; the subsequent increase in cooperative hunting of large animals; and the transition from hunting and gathering to food production, which began approximately 10,000 years ago.
The author links this last phase to the archaeological examination of human remains from different regions of the world. The variables mentioned include dental health, malocclusion, skeletal signs interpreted as iron-deficiency anemia, infection, and bone loss. The number of specimens, the archaeological sites included, the selection criteria, the lesion assessment techniques, the statistical analyses, and any control for alternative factors are not reported in the available material.
This approach is useful for proposing an overview, but it does not allow for the estimation of a quantitative effect of agriculture on health, nor does it allow for the clear separation of the role of diet from that of sedentary lifestyle, overcrowding, increased exposure to pathogens, physical labor, and environmental conditions.
Results
The central finding relevant to the book is descriptive: according to the author's summary, the transition to a diet more focused on domesticated grains and lower meat consumption was accompanied, in the archaeological record, by a decline in health. The indicators listed include worsening dental health, more occlusal anomalies, more signs interpreted as iron-deficiency anemia, more infections, and bone loss.
In plain terms, the claim is that some skeletons and teeth from ancient agricultural populations show more traces of biological stress or disease compared to what is observed in other pre-agricultural contexts. However, the abstract does not report absolute values, percentages, confidence intervals, statistical significance values, or quantitative comparisons between groups. It is therefore not possible to establish from the available material how large the differences were, in which regions they were most marked, or whether they were constant over time.
The abstract also attributes some risks of contemporary societies to sedentary lifestyles and excessive consumption of high-fat foods. This passage is not the reason why the publication is cited in the book's paragraph and does not constitute the focus of this review.
Interpretation
The biological significance of the publication is that agricultural production did not just change the menu: it also changed the way of life. More stable and larger communities could rely more heavily on a few crops, live in closer proximity, and face new labor demands. All these factors can influence teeth, skeletal growth, and vulnerability to infections.
The segment actually documented by the analyzed study is therefore: transition towards agriculture and a diet more focused on cereals → presence, in various archaeological series, of more indicators of poor health. The connection does not equate to proving a single chain of the type “less meat causes anemia, infections, and bone loss.” Bone lesions are, in fact, indirect indicators: a lesion can have multiple causes and, in particular, some cranial signs traditionally associated with anemia do not allow for a certain diagnosis on their own.
Regarding the narrative of “The Choice to Live in Health or Illness” by Dr. A. Colonnese and R. Panzironi, the scientific correspondence is therefore present at a historical-archaeological level. The strength of the causal inference remains limited because the available publication does not provide complete methodological details and because diet, infections, population density, and physical labor were closely intertwined in early agricultural societies.
Independent confirming evidence
Bioarchaeological research conducted at Çatalhöyük, a large Neolithic settlement in Anatolia dating between 7100 and 5950 BC, confirms the passage in the book regarding the potential deterioration of health conditions due to sedentary lifestyles and dependence on domesticated plants. By examining human remains and the archaeological context over a period of nearly 1,200 years, the authors reported higher biological costs associated with community life, including greater exposure to disease and increased labor demands, in relation to population growth, housing density, and reliance on domesticated plant carbohydrates [1]. This is direct confirmation of the plausibility of the general framework, but it concerns a single site and does not allow for isolating the contribution of cereals alone.
A broad comparison of skeletal remains from Central and Southeastern Europe has provided independent evidence regarding the stress of early agriculture. The authors observed that Neolithic farmers had, on average, reduced stature, body mass, and lower limb proportions compared to late Mesolithic hunter-gatherer-fishers and later agricultural populations [2]. For the reader, this suggests less favorable growth conditions in some early farming communities. However, the study does not prove that the change depended exclusively on the nutritional quality of the diet: physical activity, infections, social inequalities, and variable access to resources may also contribute.
A third study examined seven oral indicators in eleven skeletal samples from Southeastern Arabia, from the late Neolithic to the Bronze Age. In populations of the Umm an-Nar horizon, compared to older groups, cavities, lesions around the roots, and tooth loss before death increased; values were higher in inland groups compared to coastal ones [3]. This result specifically confirms the part of the narrative regarding the potential increase in dental pathologies with a greater importance of crops. The difference between the coast and the interior, however, shows that marine resources, local dietary practices, and other factors could significantly modify the effect.
Taken together, these studies support a convergent but non-linear chain: changes in subsistence and sedentary life can be associated with greater biological stress, while the manifestations observable in teeth and bones vary from population to population. None of them directly demonstrate, for all ancient agricultural communities, the presence of iron-deficiency anemia or a reduction in bone mineral density.
Conflicting evidence
A comparison between Natufian hunter-gatherers and Neolithic populations of the Southern Levant challenges the idea of inevitable dental deterioration following the advent of agriculture. The study evaluated 1,160 Natufian teeth and 804 Neolithic teeth. Caries rates were low and very similar in both groups, 6.4% in Natufians and 6.7% in Neolithic populations; periapical lesions and tooth loss before death were also similar [4].
This result is directly relevant because it indicates that the transition from hunting and gathering to food production did not necessarily lead to an increase in dental pathologies in every region. The authors suggested that food consistency, preparation techniques, and the use of teeth as tools contributed to the observed differences. No directly conflicting evidence sufficiently relevant to all other indicators mentioned in the book, such as bone infections, anemia, and bone tissue loss, has been identified; this does not prove the absence of contrary findings.
Summary table of evidence
The table distinguishes the original synthesis from independent research and shows that the archaeological picture is convergent, but not uniform.
| Reference | Study type | Population or model | Main result | Direction of evidence | Strength of evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Original study | Archaeological-evolutionary narrative synthesis | Archaeological human remains from various regions, sample size not reported | Associates the transition to agriculture with more dental problems, signs of anemia, infections, and bone loss | biologically consistent evidence | preliminary |
| [1] | Observational bioarchaeological | Human remains from Çatalhöyük, Neolithic Anatolia | Dependence on domesticated plants, population density, and sedentary lifestyle coincide with greater disease exposure and labor demands | direct confirmation | moderate |
| [2] | Comparative observational bioarchaeological | Skeletal remains from Central and Southeastern Europe | Neolithic farmers show lower average stature and body mass than Mesolithic and later agricultural groups | indirect confirmation | moderate |
| [3] | Observational bioarchaeological | Eleven skeletal samples from Southeastern Arabia | In the Umm an-Nar horizon, caries, periapical lesions, and tooth loss increase, especially in the interior | direct confirmation | moderate |
| [4] | Comparative observational bioarchaeological | 1,160 Natufian teeth and 804 Neolithic teeth from the Southern Levant | Caries, periapical lesions, and tooth loss are similar before and after the agricultural transition | discordant evidence | moderate |
Confirmation of the evidence
Claim in the book
In paragraph 1.1.3 of “The Choice to Live in Health or Illness” by Dr. A. Colonnese and R. Panzironi, the central claim is that human remains from various regions show a deterioration in health status in the period following the agricultural revolution, with more cavities, occlusal anomalies, iron-deficiency anemia, bone infections, and loss of mineral density.
Agriculture and increased sedentary lifestyle → modified diet and living conditions → biological stress and greater exposure to diseases → dental and skeletal alterations in some populations
The publication subject to the Evidence Review was used in the book to support the following passage: after the transition to agricultural production, archaeological evidence from various populations shows an increase in certain indicators of poorer health, particularly dental and skeletal.
The inclusion of this study in the section "The Choice to Live in Health or Illness" by Dr. A. Colonnese and R. Panzironi is justified because the original synthesis explicitly links the agricultural transition to a set of archaeological indicators of poor health. Independent evidence confirms important parts of this same narrative: at Çatalhöyük, sedentary life, population growth, and dependence on domesticated plants coincide with greater exposure to disease and higher labor demands [1]; in Central and Southeastern Europe, Neolithic farmers show, on average, lower growth indicators compared to pre-agricultural and later agricultural groups [2]; in Southeastern Arabia, certain dental pathologies increase during specific phases and contexts of agricultural expansion [3].
This confirmation is neither absolute nor universal. Comparisons in the Southern Levant did not reveal a significant increase in cavities or other major dental indicators following the transition to food production [4]. Furthermore, none of the additional research studies alone proves the entire sequence proposed in the book, nor do they allow for attributing all lesions solely to a reduction in meat or the introduction of grains. The most consistent explanation is multifactorial: diet, population density, infections, physical activity, and the environment all interacted with one another.
Overall level of confirmation
MODERATE CONFIRMATION
The narrative is supported by independent studies on human remains that document growth stress, increased health pressures, and, in some contexts, an increase in dental pathologies. The confirmation remains moderate because the effects are not uniform across regions and because archaeological evidence does not allow for every skeletal sign to be attributed with certainty to a single dietary cause.
Conclusions
The study analyzed pertinently supports the section of the book dedicated to the worsening of certain health indicators following the establishment of agriculture. Independent research confirms that, in various ancient communities, sedentary lifestyles, population growth, dependence on crops, and changed living conditions could coincide with greater biological stress and certain dental pathologies.
However, this picture does not authorize a universal rule that agriculture always worsened health or that grains alone were responsible for the observed alterations. The evidence is moderately supported on an archaeological level and requires an interpretation that is attentive to the geographical, dietary, environmental, and social context of each population.
Overall assessment
The correspondence between the study and the book's paragraph is fairly well supported: both describe archaeological indicators of poorer health in some ancient agricultural populations. The narrative is confirmed by independent evidence, but only moderately, as results vary between regions and do not isolate a single nutritional cause.
References
[1] Bioarchaeology of Neolithic Çatalhöyük reveals fundamental transitions in health, mobility, and lifestyle in early farmers
[2] Early Life Conditions and Physiological Stress following the Transition to Farming in Central/Southeast Europe: Skeletal Growth Impairment and 6000 Years of Gradual Recovery
Editorial note
Artificial Intelligence was used solely as a tool to support editorial and documentary work. All content, interpretations, bibliographic citations and conclusions have been verified, reviewed and approved by the author, who assumes full scientific responsibility for them.
The manuscript was also subject to independent peer review prior to publication.
To ensure maximum transparency, the article's complete history — including the dates of submission, review, acceptance and publication, as well as information on the peer review process — is available on the dedicated Article History page.