The effects of fats and proteins on glycemic responses in people without diabetes vary with waist circumference, fasting plasma insulin, and fiber intake - Evidence review
In twenty adults without diabetes, proteins and fats added to glucose reduced the glycemic response in a dose-dependent manner; per gram, the protein effect was greater. The magnitude varied with waist circumference, baseline insulin, and habitual fiber intake. Independent studies confirm the phenomenon in the acute phase, although it cannot be considered a universally applicable mechanism.
- Published 11/11/2026
- Updated 12/11/2026
- Article history
ABSTRACT
The analyzed study evaluated how different amounts of protein and fat, added to a drink containing 50 g of glucose, modified blood glucose levels after consumption in 20 people without diabetes. Both macronutrients reduced the glycemic response progressively as the dose increased, while the effect attributed to protein was greater than that attributed to fat. The magnitude of the protein effect was associated with waist circumference and habitual fiber intake; the effect of fat was associated with fasting plasma insulin.
In section 2.3 of "The Choice to Live in Health or Illness" by Dr. A. Colonnese and R. Panzironi, the publication contributes primarily to the narrative that proteins and fats can attenuate the glycemic spike when consumed with carbohydrates, with a more marked effect from proteins for the same quantity. Independent studies confirm that proteins can acutely reduce postprandial glycemia and that fats can delay gastric emptying and the glycemic peak. However, the effects change based on the type of food, the dose, the sequence of intake, and the person's metabolic characteristics. The observed association with fiber, waist circumference, and baseline insulin requires more robust confirmation.
Analyzed study
The effects of fat and protein on glycemic responses in nondiabetic humans vary with waist circumference, fasting plasma insulin, and dietary fiber intake
PMID: 16988118
The research question was whether adding protein and fat to a fixed amount of glucose could reduce the rise in glycemia after consumption, and whether this response varied in relation to the metabolic and dietary characteristics of the participants. In simple terms, the authors verified whether the body reacted to the same glucose load differently when protein or fat was also present in the drink.
The hypothesis was that the two macronutrients would reduce the glycemic response according to a dose-response relationship, meaning with an increasing effect as the amount consumed increased. The authors also explored whether fasting plasma insulin, waist circumference, and habitual diet could explain some of the individual differences.
The reason for its relevance to section 2.3 of “The Choice to Live in Health or Illness” by Dr. A. Colonnese and R. Panzironi is specific: the study documents that protein and fat, when added to glucose, reduce the acute glycemic response and that, in the experimental model used, the effect of protein was greater than that of fat. However, it does not directly measure insulin secretion after each combination of nutrients, gastric emptying, gut hormones, or long-term clinical outcomes. Therefore, it can support the segment regarding the reduction of postprandial glycemia, but it does not, on its own, prove the entire physiological chain described in the book.
Materials and methods of the original study
The available material is only the abstract; therefore, information not included in the abstract is not present in the available material. The study included 20 people without diabetes. Ten participants had fasting plasma insulin levels equal to or less than 40 pmol/L, and ten had levels greater than 40 pmol/L. Fasting plasma insulin is the concentration of insulin in the blood after an overnight Fasting; it does not, by itself, equate to a diagnosis of insulin resistance.
Participants consumed 50 g of glucose dissolved in 250 mL of water, with the addition of 0, 5, 10, or 30 g of fat and/or protein. Each fat level was tested with each protein level. The abstract reports that the individuals were studied on 18 occasions after 10-14 hour overnight fasts, but it does not fully clarify the distribution of individual visits or the order of the trials.
Habitual diet was assessed using a three-day food diary. The primary variable was the glycemic response induced by glucose, i.e., the increase in blood glucose concentration after intake. The authors analyzed the relationship between the effects of protein and fat and waist circumference, fasting plasma insulin, and habitually consumed nutrients. The available material does not report complete inclusion or exclusion criteria, sex, age, body mass index, analytical technique for glucose, randomization methods, intervals between trials, or full details of the statistical analyses.
Results
In the experimental model, both proteins and fats reduced the glycemic response to glucose in a linear and dose-dependent manner within the range of 0 to 30 g. This means that as the added amount increased, the rise in glycemia after the drink tended to decrease. The effects of the two macronutrients were described as independent: no statistically significant interaction between fats and proteins was observed, although the value reported for the interaction was close to the conventional threshold of statistical significance, P = 0.051.
According to the reported analysis, gram for gram, proteins reduced the glycemic response approximately twice as much as fats, with P < 0.001. In the conclusion of the abstract, the authors described the effect of proteins as approximately triple that of fats. Since the available text does not include tables, complete statistical models, or absolute glycemia values, it is not possible to determine precisely from which analysis the difference between the "approximately twice" and "approximately three times" phrasing derives. However, the observed direction remains clear: the addition of proteins produced a greater glycemic reduction compared to the addition of the same amount of fats.
The effect of proteins was greater in people with a larger waist circumference, with an inverse correlation between waist circumference and the glycemic effect of the protein: r = -0.56; P = 0.011. It was also greater in participants with a higher habitual intake of dietary fiber: r = -0.60; P = 0.005. An inverse correlation here indicates that as those characteristics increased, the reduction in the glycemic response attributed to proteins also increased. The effect of fats, on the other hand, was positively associated with fasting plasma insulin; P = 0.029, and was not associated with waist circumference or habitual diet. The abstract does not report the absolute quantities of the glycemic reductions in the different subgroups.
The authors explicitly warned that the conclusions might not be applicable to solid meals. This limitation is important: a glucose drink with added nutrients does not fully replicate the digestion, physical structure, and absorption rate of an ordinary meal.
Interpretation
The main takeaway is that blood glucose levels following a glucose load do not depend solely on the grams of glucose ingested. In the specific model studied, proteins and fats attenuated the glycemic peak, with proteins having a greater average effect per gram added. This is the passage that corresponds to the statement in the book that proteins and fats act as modulators of the glycemic response.
From a physiological perspective, a possible explanation is that proteins influence both insulin secretion and gut hormones, as well as the rate at which the stomach transfers its contents into the intestine. Fats can slow down gastric emptying—the passage of food from the stomach to the intestine—thereby spreading the arrival of glucose into the bloodstream over a longer period. The study analyzed, however, did not measure these mechanisms. Their attribution therefore remains a biologically plausible interpretation, not a result directly observed in this publication.
Individual associations should also be interpreted with caution. The fact that the glycemic reduction linked to proteins was greater in people with a larger waist circumference or higher dietary fiber intake does not prove that abdominal adiposity or fiber causes that effect. The sample size was small, dietary habits were estimated using a three-day food diary, and the analyses were exploratory. In particular, the study does not demonstrate that fiber acts through the gut microbiota or incretin hormones, nor that the effect of fats necessarily decreases in people with hyperinsulinemia.
Independent confirmatory evidence
Direct confirmation of the protein-related segment comes from a randomized crossover study conducted on nine healthy men. On different days, participants received glucose, protein in the form of gelatin, or glucose plus gelatin. The addition of 30 g of protein to 50 g of glucose reduced the glycemic response compared to glucose alone, with P < 0.005, and increased the half-emptying time of the stomach, with P < 0.05. The study therefore supports the passage in the book stating that protein added to carbohydrates can attenuate the glycemic spike. Since the sample was very small, male, and healthy, it primarily confirms an acute effect under experimental conditions, not a long-term clinical consequence [1].
Regarding the fat-related segment, a randomized crossover study evaluated six men with type 2 diabetes who consumed mashed potatoes after water, olive oil taken before the meal, or oil incorporated into the meal. Oil taken before the meal markedly slowed gastric emptying compared to the other conditions, P < 0.0001, and delayed the postprandial rise in glycemia, P = 0.03. It also reduced the responses of insulin and GIP, an intestinal hormone involved in the response to nutrients, while increasing GLP-1, a hormone that helps regulate glycemia and gastric emptying. This mechanistically confirms that fat can spread the glycemic rise over time; however, it does not prove that all types, doses, and methods of fat consumption have the same effect [2].
A meta-analysis of acute controlled studies examined 154 experimental comparisons between meals containing carbohydrates with or without added protein, in adults without diabetes and in people with type 1 or type 2 diabetes. In adults without diabetes, the addition of milk or plant-based proteins reduced the area under the glucose curve—that is, the overall exposure to glycemia after the meal—and increased the area under the insulin curve. This independent synthesis reinforces the general direction observed in the original study: protein added to a carbohydrate-rich meal tends to reduce the acute glycemic response. However, the authors noted high heterogeneity among the studies and differences based on the type of protein and metabolic status [3].
Conflicting evidence
The same meta-analysis that confirms the average effect of proteins also shows why it is incorrect to turn it into a universal rule. In people with type 2 diabetes, the reduction in glycemic area associated with proteins was smaller and less uniform compared to adults without diabetes. In the few comparisons available for type 1 diabetes, the addition of proteins was associated with a 40% increase in the glycemic area. These results do not contradict the experimental data from the study analyzed in people without diabetes, but they indicate that the clinical context substantially modifies the response [3].
No directly conflicting evidence sufficiently relevant to demonstrate the opposite of the main result in people without diabetes subjected to a comparable glucose load has been identified. This does not prove the absence of contrary results. In particular, the associations in the original study with waist circumference, habitual fiber intake, and fasting insulin do not have equally specific independent confirmations and should not be considered established causal mechanisms.
Summary table of evidence
The table distinguishes the study that is the subject of the review from the independent publications used to confirm or contextualize the specific narrative of the book's paragraph.
| Reference | Study type | Population or model | Main result | Direction of evidence | Strength of evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Original study | Dose-response experimental study | 20 adults without diabetes | Protein and fat added to 50 g of glucose reduced the glycemic response; the protein effect was greater. | direct confirmation | moderate |
| [1] | Randomized crossover | 9 healthy men | Adding gelatin to glucose reduced postprandial glycemia and slowed gastric emptying. | direct confirmation | moderate |
| [2] | Randomized crossover | 6 men with type 2 diabetes | Oil before the meal slowed gastric emptying and delayed the glycemic spike. | biologically consistent evidence | moderate |
| [3] | Systematic review and meta-analysis of acute crossover studies | Adults without diabetes and with type 1 or type 2 diabetes; 154 comparisons | Protein added to carbohydrates generally reduced glycemic exposure in adults without diabetes, but the effect varied according to context and type of diabetes. | discordant evidence | moderate |
Confirmation of the evidence
Claim in the book
In section 2.3 of “The Choice to Live in Health or Illness” by Dr. A. Colonnese and R. Panzironi, the central claim is that proteins and fats, when accompanying carbohydrates, can attenuate the postprandial glycemia increase through different mechanisms; for the same quantity, proteins were found to be two to three times more effective than fats. The section adds that the response may vary according to individual metabolic characteristics and dietary habits.
Carbohydrates with proteins or fats → lower or delayed glycemic increase → modulation by individual characteristics and habitual diet composition
The publication subject to the Evidence Review was used in the book to support the following passage: the addition of proteins and fats to a glucose load reduces the acute glycemic response, with an average effect of proteins greater than that of fats per gram added; the magnitude of the effect can vary between individuals.
The correspondence between the original publication and the paragraph is direct for the first segment of the narrative: in the specific experiment, proteins and fats reduced the increase in glycemia caused by glucose, and proteins exerted a greater reduction. An independent study in healthy men confirmed that adding protein to glucose reduces the glycemic response and slows gastric emptying [1]. A second study showed that fat consumed before a carbohydrate-rich meal can delay the rise in glycemia through a marked slowing of gastric emptying [2].
Independent literature therefore confirms the essential part of the narrative contained in “The Choice to Live in Health or Illness” by Dr. A. Colonnese and R. Panzironi: the composition of the meal can modify the glycemic response beyond just the quantity of carbohydrates. The available meta-analysis confirms an acute glycemic reduction on average associated with proteins added to carbohydrates in adults without diabetes, but also points out that the magnitude and even the direction of the effect can change in people with diabetes and according to the type of protein [3].
The more individualized segment of the narrative remains less confirmed. The original study observed associations between the effect of proteins, waist circumference, and habitual fiber intake, and between the effect of fats and fasting insulin. These associations are relevant and interesting, but they have not been validated by equally targeted independent studies. Furthermore, the mechanism proposed in the book involving the gut microbiota and incretin hormones was not measured by the original publication.
Overall level of confirmation
MODERATE CONFIRMATION
The acute reduction of the glycemic response when proteins or fats accompany carbohydrates is supported by the original study and by converging independent evidence. The quantitative superiority of proteins over fats and the modulation due to waist circumference, fiber, and basal insulin, however, remain dependent on the experimental context and require broader validation.
Conclusions
The study analyzed pertinently supports the idea that the glycemic response to a glucose load can be attenuated by the addition of protein and fat. In its experimental model, the effect of protein was greater. Independent evidence confirms that protein can acutely reduce glycemia after a carbohydrate-rich meal and that fats can delay the rise by slowing gastric emptying.
The narrative is moderately supported but requires precision. The data do not allow us to conclude that every protein- or fat-rich meal produces the same effect, nor that the associations with fiber, abdominal adiposity, and fasting insulin are causal. Responses depend on the meal matrix, the dose, the type of macronutrient, and the individual's metabolic state.
Overall assessment
The narrative is moderately supported: proteins and fats can attenuate or delay the acute glycemic response to carbohydrates, with consistent mechanistic evidence. The greater effect of proteins is fairly well supported in adults without diabetes, while the variability linked to fiber, waist circumference, and basal insulin remains preliminary.
References
[1] Effects of protein on glycemic and incretin responses and gastric emptying after oral glucose in healthy subjects
[2] Effects of Fat on Gastric Emptying of and the Glycemic, Insulin, and Incretin Responses to a Carbohydrate Meal in Type 2 Diabetes
Editorial note
Artificial Intelligence was used solely as a tool to support editorial and documentary work. All content, interpretations, bibliographic citations and conclusions have been verified, reviewed and approved by the author, who assumes full scientific responsibility for them.
The manuscript was also subject to independent peer review prior to publication.
To ensure maximum transparency, the article's complete history — including the dates of submission, review, acceptance and publication, as well as information on the peer review process — is available on the dedicated Article History page.